I want to deeply thank author Brant Randall (aka Bruce Cook) for taking the time to stop by Cafe of Dreams and posting a wonderful guest post. If you haven't checked out his book, Blood Harvest (click here for my review) please do so - you will be thrilled that you did!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Does history exist?
Does history exist?
Does an author owe anything to the historical record? Is history a verifiable, testable, provable thing?My recent novel, Blood Harvest, is an attempt to give a new perspective to a past in the United States that is still within living memory. When most people hear the background of my story they express either astonishment or disbelief. A few confirm it and add more details to what I have learned.
In the 1920s the Ku Klux Klan had as many as six million members in 35 states. It controlled state legislatures. It controlled the Democratic National Convention in 1924, stalemating the nomination of Al Smith (a Catholic) for 103 ballots.
Its power base was NOT the south. It was the northeast and Midwest. It certainly was anti-black, but in the 1920s it was especially anti-immigrant, anti-Semitic, and anti-Catholic. There was a rally of 20,000 Klansmen in Worcester Massachusetts in 1924 that ended in a riot, where the opposition was the Knights of Columbus. There are films of the KKK marching down Pennsylvania in front of the Capitol in 1925, fifteen thousand strong, in full Klan regalia.
My question to you is this: where was all this information when I was falling asleep in high school history class during the height of the civil rights movement?
This all started because of a story my grandmother told me. She lived to the age of ninety-six and died in 2002. She was a Scotch-Irish girl from rural New England, one of twelve children, though two died in infancy.
I knew she had married young, perhaps at sixteen, though she sometimes claimed she had been eighteen. She said that after her wedding day she never returned to her home town. I assumed that she eloped or otherwise angered her parents. At one point I asked if her parents disliked my grandfather, who I remembered as personable and charming.
She claimed that they liked him very much. He was a perfect example of the immigrant success story. Came to America from Greece at sixteen, without any English. Started working the next day. Within five years he owned his own restaurant, and in another five he added a chain of candy shops and drug stores.
"So why didn’t you ever return to your home town?"
"It was those dumb clucks." She used this expression only when quite angry. "My brother-in-law didn’t think it right for a white girl to marry a non-white European."
This was new territory to me, but when I read my grandfather’s immigration papers I found that southern Europeans—the Greeks, Spanish, Italians, and Turks—were classified thus until 1912. But it was her next revelation that stunned me.
It wasn’t dumb "clucks." It was dumb "klux." It was the KKK that had driven my grandparents from the town. This was not consistent with what I had learned in my history classes, and so I began to research.
I read a number of histories of the period, then histories of the KKK. I did research on the net and found photos and film of KKK rallies in front of the White House in the. I read contemporary accounts in newspapers of the day. (You can see the film on my YouTube book trailer http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XAJM6Nbbq9Q http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XAJM6Nbbq9Q )
Best of all I interviewed friends and family whose memories extend back to the 1920s. Their reminiscences were wonderful and invaluable. I found that as they spoke of their childhood they often dropped into the jargon and slang of the times.
In fiction as well as in non-fiction, writers very often take liberties with their material to tell a good story or make a point. But how much is too much? Have I told a "true" story in my novel?
Since three eyewitnesses to the same event come up with three different (sometimes contradictory) accounts, I don’t put too much value on "history" as written by historians. They always write with the filter of their own culture and education.
And anyway the word history contains the word "story" within it. As long as I’m not preaching I can shape the story—and history—as I wish.
Still, all this elision and revision of history is troubling. I currently teach cinema at a college where 50% of my students are attending on international visas. In one discussion I was asking what the name for World War II was in their home country. (Since not all countries fought in WWI, I expected there to be some variation.) Mexico calls it the Great War, a term used in the United Kingdom for World War I. Vietnam has no name for it. And a Japanese student told me it is the War Against American Imperialism.
As Nietzsche said, "There are no facts, only interpretations."
4 comments:
What a great post! The author's story about his grandmother and her husband being run out of town by the KKK, reminded me of the a story I'd heard when I was about 13or 14 years old.
I was visiting relatives in small town Pennsylvania (I was living in California at the time) and was shocked by the fact that all of the faces around me were white. My grandmother proceeded to tell me a story about how a black family had tried to move into the town many years before I was born, but the residents made it so uncomfortable for them that they didn't stay. From what my grandmother said, other families who weren't considered white were forced out as well. No one mentioned the KKK and so I don't know if they had anything to do with it. I heard bits and pieces of stories like that in school, but there was never really any time to delve into it further in the classroom. Teachers had to fit in so much information in a short amount of time. History was definitely watered down.
I agree about history being subjective. I think the examples the author gave proves that point well. When I was a teen and into my adulthood, a Finnish friend and I would have great conversations via letters about this very issue, discussing some of the differences in perspectives and what is taught in school.
Awesome guest post! I immediately was brought back in time to when I was about 14. The KKK had a rally in our small town in CT. I remember them in their white hoods screaming hatred at the cars passing by. It was scary.
--Anna
Diary of an Eccentric
Here is yet more affirmation that the KKK was active in the northeast. By the way, my grandparents were run out of McDonald, Pennsylvania, about 1924.
Brant Randall/Bruce Cook
货架货架叉车叉车工具箱工具箱工作台工作台托盘托盘文件柜文件柜卡板卡板垃圾桶垃圾桶货架厂货架厂购物车购物车塑料桶塑料桶北京货架北京货架物流设备物流设备手推车手推车塑料托盘塑料托盘周转箱周转箱仓储设备仓储设备塑料箱塑料箱仓储货架仓储货架货架公司货架公司仓储架仓储架液压车液压车超市货架超市货架搬运车搬运车木托盘木托盘工具车工具车垃圾箱垃圾箱上海货架上海货架隔离网隔离网储物柜储物柜安全柜安全柜南京货架南京货架仓储笼仓储笼密集架密集架更衣柜更衣柜塑料周转箱塑料周转箱线棒线棒广州货架广州货架置物架置物架栈板栈板重型货架重型货架仓库货架仓库货架护栏护栏护栏网护栏网仓库隔离网仓库隔离网公路护栏公路护栏高速公路护栏高速公路护栏堆高车堆高车整理箱整理箱深圳货架深圳货架
Post a Comment